Today I ran the Las Vegas Spartan Race, out at Lake Las Vegas with the lovely people pictured above. Two of them are named Zach. This amuses me.
In October
I participated in the Las Vegas Tough Mudder. Both of these events are "mud runs," less than half a marathon in length and replete with military-style obstacles. They're also outdoors, making them much more difficult and tiring than other runs.
(On average I can run a 9.5-10 minute mile on asphalt. In the desert, that changes drastically.)
Since the Spartan Race is put on by different people than Tough Mudder, I compared the two a lot in my head, and thought I post my experience based on a couple of contrasts:
RACE CAMP: Both were similar. You showed up, flashed your ID, signed a waiver and got your race packet. This included a number for you to pin on, and then someone would write that same number on your arms in black marker. TM used a less potent marker, most of the number washed off during the course. SR's marker clogged my pores and I had to use a pumice stone to get it off. Some of it is still there and I now have abrasions, so yeah. BUT, the Spartan people did give us nifty little Spartan helmet stamps for our faces, which...also...didn't wash off...
HEATS/STARTING LINE: TM had you hop a six-foot wall and climb into what is essentially a box with the other people in your heat. They played the national anthem, then "Eye of the Tiger," then told you to have a good time and call for a medic if you're injured.
SR had some dude at the head of the crowd shouting champion stuff about how you're a Spartan and this is a battlefield, etc. etc. We heard him go through the same spiel every fifteen minutes when we were at the race camp. It got old. But, he did pop a smoke bomb and chucked it for us when we started, which was cool.
OBSTACLES: TM's obstacles seemed to be more endurance-based for a cardiocentric workout. Others were really "showy," like flaming hay bales or electrical shock wires. I was personally disappointed in some of TM's obstacles. Most of the ice in the Arctic Freeze was melted, and the electrical shock wires weren't on by the time my heat went through them--and that was only the afternoon.
SR's obstacles seemed to deal more with muscular force. Pick up a sandbag, carry it through an obstacle course. Bind your ankles and bunny-hop over these hay bales. Pick up this 80-lb weight and take it up there. Flip this tractor tire six times.
Another key difference: each TM obstacle had a bypass. If you didn't want to do it, you could just walk around. Each SR obstacle was manned by a race coordinator, and if you tried to bypass it or if you failed, they made you do 30 burpees on the spot. You don't want to do 30 burpees.
Both had an equal amount of "crawl on your belly through gross mud or else barb wire will cut you" obstacles. They had comparable amounts of uphill and downhill running, and while SR had less water obstacles, they did have a longer swim, which helped to get rid of the mud.
WATER STOPS/OUTHOUSES: TM had more outhouses, but about the same amount of water stops. However, they had snacks and stuff too, while SR didn't. SR also seemed to run low on water. We never got shorted, but we could see the supplies dwindling after a few hours.
FINISH LINE: TM had you run through "scary" electrical wires that weren't on. SR required you to jump over a pile of flaming logs, then get whacked by gladiators holding padded sticks. You tell me which one makes for a better photo op.
CLEANUP: Oh man, SR definitely wins this one. TM set up what was basically a human car wash, you walked through a wood-and-PVC scaffold and the staff hosed you down until they figured you were good. But you weren't good. You were cold, still half-dirty and all-miserable.
SR, on the other hand, set up a rubber platform with a bajillion hoses and you could hose yourself down, hose down your stuff, wring out the dirt, hose it again, take as long as you needed to get the bulk of the groties off you. It was much, much better.
TEAMS AND TIMES: SR definitely has the competitive edge here--some teams even competed for cash prizes. I didn't see that come up much at TM (though I've heard they have such events elsewhere.) A big difference is that SR gives you a chip that you tie to your wrist, and it tracks you across the course. By the time I finished it had given me my time, my rank among the whole racing body, my rank among men, and my rank among men my age. (I was in the top 25%, which was pretty cool.)
MAP: TM posted a complete map of the course online, with obstacle descriptions. SR only handed out said maps on-site, and didn't really tell us where to get them.
PERKS: Both events landed me a decent shirt. TM's shirt was breathable lycra Under Armour; SR's is a regular cotton poly T-shirt. SR also gave me a medal. TM had more free food at the finish line. Immediately following a mud run, I would prefer the food. But the medal is cool.
PHOTOGRAPHY: Still don't know what SR's photography deals will be like. TM had photographers throughout the course, but I didn't order any shots because of their outrageous prices. Some of the best photos were when my wife shot us from the spectator trail. (Whoops, that sounds bad.)
So it's apples to oranges in the end. Mud runs are a fun way to get in shape and spend a day with your friends doing something to give you bragging rights. Find one near you, make sure you check out the trail, and go for it!